Sanitary and Phytosanitary
Information Management System
Specific Trade Concerns
Other SPS Documents
Enquiry Points/Notification Authorities
Compare notifications between two time periods
Definitions of groups
STC Number - 27
Brazil; Chile; South Africa; Uruguay
First date raised:
, paras. 30-31
Dates subsequently raised:
March 1998 (
, paras. 6-8)
June 1998 (
, paras. 31-33)
Number of times subsequently raised:
0805 Citrus fruit, fresh or dried.
Primary subject keyword:
Good Offices/Consultations/Dispute Settlement; Plant health; Equivalence
Date reported as resolved:
Extracts from SPS Committee meeting summary reports
In July 1997, Argentina requested bilateral consultations with EC experts on the proposed measure on citrus canker, and that the measure be suspended during these consultations. South Africa requested that the European Communities reassess its measures in light of the fact that South Africa was free from citrus canker. The European Communities noted that it was preparing a response to the Argentine concern, and was open to consultations with interested parties. The European Communities was moving from a system with internal restrictions in the production areas of Italy, Greece and Corsica to a truly single market with free movement of goods. With no restriction on internal movement of fruit, and considering the risk of introduction and the related economic consequences, alternative protection for the main producing areas had to be considered. This included monitoring requirements in the exporting country, treatment and certification. The European Communities considered that its measures were based on science and minimized trade effects.
In March 1998, the European Communities reported that, in response to constructive consultations organized by the Chairman and involving Argentina, Chile, Uruguay, Brazil and South Africa, the measure had been revised and subsequently adopted. The revised text included the possibility for recognition of equivalent certification systems. Argentina agreed, but noted that negotiations on equivalence were not yet finished.
In June 1998, the European Communities indicated that it had come to the conclusion that, for the time being, Argentina could not objectively demonstrate the equivalence of its control measures with EC requirements. Argentina requested information on the risk assessment undertaken by the European Communities.
In March 2004, Argentina reported that the issue had been resolved with the European Communities.
© World Trade Organization 2019
ver 18.104.22.168733 (12/06/2019 03:26 PM)